Whose Truth?

Photo credit: Getty Images

Why does she wrestle guilt and doubt daily? Is she who she says she is? Is she real? Authentic? Can she trust her own opinions and intuition, or would she do well to have someone else make decisions for her? Even small decisions send her into a heart-pounding tailspin—like what outfit to wear to the company party or what kind of take-out she wants on a Friday evening. She has no idea why. This debilitating self-scrutiny encroaches on her soaring career and strains the few relationships she has managed to retain.

With every passing day she becomes more unsure and therefore, more concerned about how to carry on. Maybe she should see a therapist. Maybe her priest. Maybe she truly is going crazy.

Or maybe she is going to hell.

At that thought, her entire body tenses and sweat pours from her forehead. Hell. For years she has pushed that concept as far away as possible, yet it resurfaces at the most inopportune times.

Everything about her personal beliefs has changed over the past two decades. Well, nearly everything. She does believe in God and finds comfort in her spirituality. But hell? She shudders in recollection of her childhood.

She can never completely reign in her thoughts when they go there and today seems worse than ever. She pulls her thunder gray Mini Cooper into the double garage attached to her exclusive country home. She stumbles into the house, throws her coat and briefcase onto the couch in her den and collapses into the soft suede easy chair.

Everything she owns is real. Everything. Leather; hardwood; crystal; silver; suede. She wears only wool, raw silk, cotton or linen. She cannot tolerate imitation. She’s fanatical about authenticity.

Her hand moves back and forth over the armrest. It’s real. Representing a truth of sorts.

Tell the truth, girl. Her shoulders jerk involuntarily. She would recognize that voice on Tiananmen Square at noon. Shame, doubt and fear wash over her in waves.

The five-year-old child had spoken her truth to a preschool teacher that fateful day in December. The memory had never left her, but had been buried under layers of blame, shame, arguments, accusations, continual attempts to please, prayers for healing, sermons about truth and a pathological obsession for perfection.

Old theatrical characters re-emerge out of the dingy backstage of her mind. A flurry of uniformed people, doctors, nurses, teachers, counselors—in schools, hospitals, professional offices and at home. But the most terrifying of all are her mom and dad. Each of them had held one of her shoulders, demanding that she tell the real truth. Not some fairytale they believed she was making up. Just remember: There was absolutely no way he could have done that to her.

She had been tormented. She thought she had told the truth when she spoke with the teacher. She hadn’t a reason not to. Her teacher had said, “You can always tell me anything.” That’s what she had done. She was terribly confused. She cried. She was beaten. She was grilled relentlessly. She was told so frequently that her story was wrong that she began to believe an alternate story. It wasn’t her truth. It was what they demanded truth to be.

Her spoken truth had plummeted her into never-ending anguish, terror, discrimination from those in her own home, and existential doubt about her spirituality. Only, as a child, she had had no idea that this was happening.

Tonight, overcome with reemerging recollections, her body slowly crumples into an unrecognizable heap in her perfect suede chair. Oh, the countless whippings for “not telling the truth.” The hundreds of hands groping her body as men and women tried to “pray her right.” The perpetual stares of other children and their parents. The unrelenting whispers. Now, once again, she almost became that forlorn child she thought she had left behind.











Continued in Behind Each Face*

*Because this story appears in the recently published book, it is subject to restrictions as to where it can be posted in its entirety.


* revised and edited, 2015
© Julia Penner-Zook, Behind Each Face


21 thoughts on “Whose Truth?

  1. Hi Julia, this is excellent, sustained writing at its best, there are all to many stories like this, most do not get to be known, so it ism important that some one is writing them down, and sharing with any body, who could get to read this. It is so painful that many may not be able to finish reading it. I think this is important enough to re-blog and share on Facebook, google+ and pinterist. Best wishes and blessings, Charles.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Charles, your comment is so inspiring to me. Thank you! I agree that there are many whose stories are left covered. Silent. Out of sight. Even forcefully hidden.
      I can’t tell you how much I appreciate you sharing it further. It gives me much hope. Blessings and best wishes back to you as well.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for that reminder, Lynette. Undeniably, acknowledgement is a prerequisite for the process of healing. It seems to me we are tasked with and privileged to offer an environment which makes acknowledgement possible and the process safe.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Truth is perception, but pain is an emotion that forever alters that perception and scars. Its learning to process that pain correctly that helps us camouflage those scars and move forward to live a healthy, productive, happy life. Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Shell. You’ve made a perceptive observation about the relationship between pain and the experience of truth. Pain threatens to warp on so many levels; we live with the challenge of how to respond in a life giving way. Within ourselves and alongside others. Thank you for your insightful words.

      Liked by 1 person

I'd love to hear from you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.